Determining the Effect (the Social Costs) of Exclusion under the South African Exclusionary Rule: Should Factual Guilt Tilt the Scales in Favour of the Admission of Unconstitutionally Obtained Evidence?

[2012] PER 59

Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal

South Africa

Legislation Cited

Legislation Name	Provision
Evidence Act (Cth)

Cases and Articles Cited

Case Name	Citation(s)	Court	Jurisdiction	Date †	Full Text	Citation Index
S v Mokgalaka	2017 2 SACR 159		South Africa	circa 2017		5
S v Ramulifho	[2012] ZASCA 202; 2013 1 SACR 388	Supreme Court of Appeal of South Africa	South Africa	30 Nov 2012	SAFLII	37
2012 South African Law Journal 18	2012 South African Law Journal 18	South African Law Journal	South Africa	circa 2012	HeinOnline	1
"Striking a balance between the will of the people and the supremacy of the Constitution"	2012 South African Law Journal 9	South African Law Journal	South Africa	circa 2012	HeinOnline	1
Media 24 Ltd v National Prosecuting Authority (55656/10)	[2011] ZAGPPHC 64; 2011 2 SACR 321	North Gauteng High Court, Pretoria	South Africa	29 Apr 2011	SAFLII	2
R v C ô t &eacute	[2011] SCC 46; [2011] 3 SCR 215			circa 2011		3
2011 Tsar 268-282	2011 TSAR 268-282		South Africa	circa 2011		1
2011 Tsar 271	2011 TSAR 271		South Africa	circa 2011		1
2011 Tsar 269	2011 TSAR 269		South Africa	circa 2011		1
2011 Tsar 268	2011 TSAR 268		South Africa	circa 2011		1
2011 Tsar 278	2011 TSAR 278		South Africa	circa 2011		1
2011 Tsar 274	2011 TSAR 274		South Africa	circa 2011		1
Dos Santos v The State	[2010] ZASCA 73; [2010] 4 All SA 132; 2010 2 SACR 382	Supreme Court of Appeal of South Africa	South Africa	27 May 2010	SAFLII	17
Lachman v S (432/09)	[2010] ZASCA 14; [2010] 3 All SA 483; 2010 2 SACR 52	Supreme Court of Appeal of South Africa	South Africa	15 Mar 2010	SAFLII	23
"The need for clarity on whether 'suspects' may rely on section 35(5) of the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996: a comparative analysis"	[2010] Comparative and International Law Journal of Southern Africa 239	Comparative and International Law Journal of Southern Africa		circa 2010		2
"Constitutional exclusion under section 35(5) of the Constitution: Should an accused bear a 'threshold burden' of proving that his or her constitutional right has been infringed?"	2010 South African Journal of Criminal Justice 22	South African Journal of Criminal Justice	South Africa	circa 2010	HeinOnline	1
2010 South African Law Journal 695	2010 South African Law Journal 695	South African Law Journal	South Africa	circa 2010	HeinOnline	1
2010 South African Law Journal 697	2010 South African Law Journal 697	South African Law Journal	South Africa	circa 2010	HeinOnline	1
2010 South African Law Journal 699	2010 South African Law Journal 699	South African Law Journal	South Africa	circa 2010	HeinOnline	1
2010 South African Law Journal 704	2010 South African Law Journal 704	South African Law Journal	South Africa	circa 2010	HeinOnline	1
2010 South African Law Journal 705	2010 South African Law Journal 705	South African Law Journal	South Africa	circa 2010	HeinOnline	1
2010 South African Law Journal 710	2010 South African Law Journal 710	South African Law Journal	South Africa	circa 2010	HeinOnline	1
2010 South African Law Journal 712	2010 South African Law Journal 712	South African Law Journal	South Africa	circa 2010	HeinOnline	1
2010 South African Law Journal 713	2010 South African Law Journal 713	South African Law Journal	South Africa	circa 2010	HeinOnline	1
S v Mbatha	[2009] ZAKZPHC 2; 2009 2 SACR 623	Kwazulu-Natal High Court, Pietermaritzburg	South Africa	5 Mar 2009	SAFLII	26
2009 Obiter 607-627	2009 Obiter 607-627		South Africa	circa 2009		1
2009 Obiter 627	2009 Obiter 627		South Africa	circa 2009		1
R v Harrison	[2009] SCC 34; [2009] 2 SCR 494			circa 2009		5
R v Grant	(2009) 66 CR (6th) 1		Canada	circa 2009		1
S v Mavinini	[2008] ZASCA 166; [2009] 2 All SA 277; 2009 1 SACR 523	Supreme Court of Appeal of South Africa	South Africa	1 Dec 2008	SAFLII	42
Thint (Pty) Ltd v National DPP & others; Zuma & another v National DPP & others	[2008] ZACC 13; 2009 1 SA 1; 2008 2 SACR 421	Constitutional Court of South Africa	South Africa	31 Jul 2008	SAFLII	133
S v Nell	[2008] ZAWCHC 91; 2009 2 SACR 37	High Court of South Africa - Western Cape Division	South Africa	25 Apr 2008	SAFLII	15
Mthembu v S	[2008] ZASCA 51; [2008] 3 All SA 159; 2008 2 SACR 407	Supreme Court of Appeal of South Africa	South Africa	10 Apr 2008	SAFLII	11
(2002) 234 De Villiers 2008	(2002) 234 De Villiers 2008		South Africa - Orange Free State	circa 2008		1
S v Basson	2007 1 SACR 566		South Africa	circa 2007		33
Magajane v Chairperson, North West Gambling Board	[2006] ZACC 8; 2006 5 SA 250; 2006 2 SACR 447	Constitutional Court of South Africa	South Africa	8 Jun 2006	SAFLII	45
National DPP v Mohunram (173/05)	[2006] ZASCA 12; 2006 1 SACR 554; [2007] 4 All SA 704	Supreme Court of Appeal of South Africa	South Africa	17 Mar 2006	SAFLII	43
S v Hena	[2006] ZAECHC 11; 2006 2 SACR 33	Eastern Cape Division of the High Court of South Africa	South Africa	8 Mar 2006	SAFLII	13
Zuma v National DPP (14116/05)	[2006] ZAKZHC 5; [2006] 2 All SA 91; 2006 1 SACR 468	High Court of South Africa - Kwazulu Natal Division	South Africa	15 Feb 2006	SAFLII	24
R v Grant	(2006) 38 CR (6th) 58		Canada	circa 2006		1
S v August	2005 2 All SA 605		South Africa	circa 2005		3
Pillay v S	2004 2 BCLR 158		Canada - British Columbia	circa 2004		87
R v Dalley	[2002] NSWCCA 284; (2002) 132 A Crim R 169	Supreme Court of New South Wales - Court of Criminal Appeal	Australia - New South Wales	19 Jul 2002	AustLII	61
[2002] QCLLR 27	[2002] QCLLR 27		Australia - Queensland	circa 2002		1
[2002] QCLLR 29	[2002] QCLLR 29		Australia - Queensland	circa 2002		1
[2002] QCLLR 21-39	[2002] QCLLR 21-39		Australia - Queensland	circa 2002		1
NDPP v Rebuzzi	2002 1 SACR 128		South Africa	circa 2002		11
2001 South African Journal of Criminal Justice 38	2001 South African Journal of Criminal Justice 38	South African Journal of Criminal Justice	South Africa	circa 2001	HeinOnline	1
S v Ndhlovu	2001 1 SACR 85		South Africa	circa 2001		5
Ntzweli v S	2001 2 All SA 184		South Africa	circa 2001		2
2000 South African Journal of Criminal Justice 318	2000 South African Journal of Criminal Justice 318	South African Journal of Criminal Justice	South Africa	circa 2000	HeinOnline	1
2000 South African Journal of Criminal Justice 67	2000 South African Journal of Criminal Justice 67	South African Journal of Criminal Justice	South Africa	circa 2000	HeinOnline	1
"Uitsluiting van getuienis ingevolge artikel 35(5) van die Grondwet"	2000 South African Journal of Criminal Justice 57	South African Journal of Criminal Justice	South Africa	circa 2000	HeinOnline	1
[1999] QCLLR 461	[1999] QCLLR 461		Australia - Queensland	circa 1999		1
[1999] QCLLR 443-477	[1999] QCLLR 443-477		Australia - Queensland	circa 1999		1
S v Lottering	(1999) 12 BCLR 1478		Canada - British Columbia	circa 1999		8
S v Gumede	1998 5 BCLR 530		Canada - British Columbia	circa 1998		4
S v Shongwe	(1998) 9 BCLR 1170		Canada - British Columbia	circa 1998		1
S v Ngcobo	(1998) 10 BCLR 1248		Canada - British Columbia	circa 1998		6
S v Muravha	1998 JOL 3994		South Africa	circa 1998		1
1998 Tsar 20-38	1998 TSAR 20-38		South Africa	circa 1998		1
S v Mathebula	1998 1 BCLR 123		Canada - British Columbia	circa 1998		10
S v Madiba	1998 1 BCLR 38		Canada - British Columbia	circa 1998		3
S v Soci	1998 2 SACR 275		South Africa	circa 1998		11
1998 Tsar 20	1998 TSAR 20		South Africa	circa 1998		1
"The exclusion of evidence in the absence of an appropriate warning"	1997 South African Journal of Human Rights 446	South African Journal of Human Rights	South Africa	circa 1997		1
R v Feeney	(1997) 115 CCC (3d) 129		Canada	circa 1997		2
S v Desai	1997 1 All SA 298		South Africa	circa 1997		1
1997 Tsar 615-625	1997 TSAR 615-625		South Africa	circa 1997		1
1997 Tsar 615	1997 TSAR 615		South Africa	circa 1997		1
v Agnew	1996 2 SACR 535		South Africa	circa 1996		7
Ferreira v Levin NO; Vryenhoek v Powell	(1996) 1 SA 984; [1996] 3 CHRLD 389		South Africa	circa 1996	LexisNexis	281
S v Melani	1996 2 BCLR 174		Canada - British Columbia	circa 1996		3
1996 South African Journal of Criminal Justice 89	1996 South African Journal of Criminal Justice 89	South African Journal of Criminal Justice	South Africa	circa 1996	HeinOnline	1
S v Nombewu	1996 2 SACR 396; [1996] 4 All SA 621		South Africa	circa 1996		17
S v Makwanyane	[1995] ZACC 3; 1995 3 SA 391; 1995 2 SACR 1; [1996] 2 CHRLD 164	Constitutional Court of South Africa	South Africa	6 Jun 1995	SAFLII	941
S v Coales	1995 1 SACR 33		South Africa	circa 1995		23
S v Williams	(1995) 7 BCLR 861		Canada - British Columbia	circa 1995		5
1995 4 BCLR 401	1995 4 BCLR 401		Canada - British Columbia	circa 1995		75
S v January; Prokureur-Generaal, Natal v Khumalo	1994 2 SACR 801		South Africa	circa 1994		15
R v Grant	(1993) 84 CCC (3d) 173		Canada	circa 1993		2
S v Khuzwayo	1993 1 SACR 365		South Africa	circa 1993		10
"Pointing out and inadmissible confessions"	1991 South African Journal of Criminal Justice 318	South African Journal of Criminal Justice	South Africa	circa 1991	HeinOnline	1
S v Sheehama	1991 2 SACR 860		South Africa	circa 1991		1
Lam Chi-ming v R	[1991] LRC (Crim) 416			circa 1991		1
1991 South African Journal of Criminal Justice 326	1991 South African Journal of Criminal Justice 326	South African Journal of Criminal Justice	South Africa	circa 1991	HeinOnline	1
1991 South African Journal of Criminal Justice 321	1991 South African Journal of Criminal Justice 321	South African Journal of Criminal Justice	South Africa	circa 1991	HeinOnline	1
[1989] QCLLR 340-345	[1989] QCLLR 340-345		Australia - Queensland	circa 1989		1
[1989] QCLLR 326-365	[1989] QCLLR 326-365		Australia - Queensland	circa 1989		1
Black v R	(1989) 50 CCC (3d) 1		Canada	circa 1989		3
R v Jacoy	(1988) 38 CRR 290		Canada	circa 1988		7
R v Collins	[1987] 1 SCR 265; (1987) 38 DLR (4th) 508; 56 CR (3d) 193; 28 CRR 122	Supreme Court of Canada	Canada	9 Apr 1987	Supreme Court of Canada	69
[1984] McGill Law Journal 529	[1984] McGill Law Journal 529	McGill Law Journal	Canada	circa 1984	HeinOnline / LexisNexis	1
[1984] McGill Law Journal 528	[1984] McGill Law Journal 528	McGill Law Journal	Canada	circa 1984	HeinOnline / LexisNexis	1
"The exclusion of evidence under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms: What to do and what not to do"	[1984] McGill Law Journal 521	McGill Law Journal	Canada	circa 1984	HeinOnline / LexisNexis	1
S v Lebone	1965 2 SA 837		South Africa	circa 1965	LexisNexis	15
Ex Parte Minister of Justice in re R v Matemba	[1941] AD 75			circa 1941		5
996 South African Journal of Criminal Justice 83	996 South African Journal of Criminal Justice 83	South African Journal of Criminal Justice	South Africa	circa 2010	HeinOnline	1

LawCite: Privacy | Disclaimers | Conditions of Use | Acknowledgements | Feedback